POWER Prevents Corona Discharge in Power Lines
Alexandra Foley | June 10, 2014
Modernizing the power grid is a huge undertaking. The power industry is mustering up its vast engineering knowledge base to develop the components and systems that will bring us efficient and reliable electrical power for decades to come. By leveraging highly accurate simulation technology with knowledge gained over decades of analyzing in-service equipment, engineers are creating new designs as well as retrofitting proven technology.
Simulation Optimizes Power Line Design
During the project, POWER used multiphysics simulation to study corona discharge in power lines and their associated assemblies. The aim of the project was to determine if and where corona discharge occurred. Above a certain voltage, energy loss, electromagnetic (AM) radio interference, audible noise, and possible erosion of materials can occur. Using simulation to predict where corona discharge is likely to happen prior to the physical testing of hardware can, therefore, be highly beneficial for manufacturers and transmission owners.
For decades, electrical engineers have been studying the performance of in-service equipment and conducting rigorous testing in order to optimize transmission lines. Because such extensive data exists on transmission line equipment, POWER was able to use this data to build accurate simulations to quickly test the viability of new equipment. Working on a project for a Midwestern utility company, Jon Leman, Senior Project Engineer at POWER, modeled the corona discharge produced in a dead-end insulator assembly. These assemblies are high-tension mechanical linkages used to insulate energized conductors from grounded support structures at locations where the power line either turns or terminates.
A power transmission line with three phases, each with two associated dead-end assemblies.
As I mention in the article, the dead-end assemblies proposed in the study were built for use with special 345 kV transmission line equipment. Specifically, the equipment in question was engineered to withstand a multitude of harsh conditions, such as high winds and ice accumulation. One way that this is achieved is by twisting together a set of two cables. Instead of the smooth face that a single, cylindrical cable would present to the wind, the twisted cables, used in such conductors, have a continuously varying profile that helps minimize icing airfoil effects and prevent conductor galloping. A CAD drawing of the dead-end assembly studied in this project is shown in the figure below, where an insulator string provides mechanical insulation between the live conductors and the utility pole.
CAD representation of a dead-end insulator assembly.
Modeling Techniques for an Efficient Simulation
One of challenges Leman and his team faced was how to construct an accurate simulation of the dead-end assembly without modeling details that would have led to a lengthy solve-time and compromised the model’s efficiency. Leman and his team solved this problem using a few different techniques. First, instead of modeling all three phases of the transmission line, Leman determined that modeling a single phase would still provide accurate results since the spacing between phases was larger than the distance between the energized portion of the dead-end assembly and the grounded end of the assembly.
Next, Leman decided that by analyzing the electric potential along the insulator string using a 2D axisymmetric model, he could determine the effective voltage present on the cap of the last unit of the insulator string (shown in the image above and plot below). Then, when preparing the 3D model of the assembly, he could construct a lean simulation by including only the last unit of the insulator string. With this information, Leman and his team were able to set up a reasonably accurate simulation without having to introduce the computational burden of the insulator string’s complex and repetitive geometry.
2D axisymmetric model of the insulator string showing the electric potential distribution.
Sound Saturation: Preventing Buzzing and Radio Interference
Next, POWER created a simulation of the electric field strength along the surface of the dead-end assembly using the previous results as a boundary condition for the single insulator cup modeled. Using custom postprocessing based on data gathered from the field testing of similar conductors, Leman was able visualize the areas that were likely to experience harmful corona discharge.
Corona discharge occurs because of a combination of electric fields, device geometry, atmospheric conditions, and the surface condition of the conductor. Leman’s model was able to take this complex phenomenon and predict the results of a dead-end assembly that had not yet undergone physical testing.
Electric field strength at the surface of the dead-end assembly.
Leman told me, “If you’ve ever stood near a transmission line, you’ve probably heard the buzzing noise is makes.” He then explained, “Above a certain voltage, the electric field ionizes air molecules and creates corona discharge. That’s the noise you hear.”
Using multiphysics simulation, POWER was able to supply their customer with an accurate prediction of where corona discharge was likely to occur. From there, they could help them mitigate the associated buzzing noise and other effects. “I have great respect for the engineers who built the electric grid without the use of modern computing,” Leman says. “It’s important that we combine that ingenuity with the use of advanced tools to efficiently design tomorrow’s grid.”
- To learn more about the modeling techniques employed by POWER Engineers, check out the full-length story in the magazine Multiphysics Simulation, which is published as an insert to IEEE Spectrum.
- Visit the POWER Engineers website to learn more about the engineering solutions offered by this worldwide consulting company.
Computing Total Normal Flux on a Planar Surface
- Certified Consultants 28
- Chemical 37
- COMSOL Now 127
- Conference 98
- Core Functionality 53
- Electrical 84
- Fluid 66
- Interfacing 31
- Mechanical 103
- Multipurpose 12
- Tips & Tricks 32
- Trending Topics 23
- User Perspectives 77
- Video 62